I am addicted to making these
"I would die protecting you."
Shadowfire was sitting on the couch. She was alone this time, staring blankly at the ceiling.
She pulled her hoodie sleeves over her hands and flinched when she saw Ticci Toby and Clockwork together.
Yes. They did get back together. Toby broke up with her a while ago.
Toby looked at the female Demon but quickly looked away. Shadowfire's eyes turned grey-blue and she knitted her eyebrows sadly. Since that day that he told her to move on, her eyes had been that colour. They never stayed amber.
She gently got up from the couch and went to get a soda, but Jane the Killer stopped her. "Hey, we're playing seven minutes in heaven again!" she screeched. Shadowfire glared at Jane.
"I don't want to, Jane." she said with pain in her voice. The other Creepypasta's stared at her. They have never seen her this soft-hearted before.
"Why not?" Clockwork asked, mockingly. Toby was staring at the floor, one arm around the green-eyed Creepypasta.
A low growl rumbled in Shadowfire's throat. "Fine, I'll play." she said calmly, sitting on the floor.
The bag was in front of her. Shadowfire reached for it, but Jane stopped her.
"Your not picking this time, Demon." she snapped at her. She walked over to Toby and set the bag in front of him.
Toby's blush was clearly seen under his mouth guard. He flinched and reached his hand in.
Clockwork looked eagerly at Toby and shot Shadowfire a glare. It almost said, he doesn't like you anymore.
But what he chose was unexpected.
It was a small katana keychain. With the initials "SC" written on it. Toby pried his gaze off the black and silver keychain and looked at Shadowfire. His gloved hands clenched and unclenched.
Clockwork gasped in surprise. "No Toby you can't." she said with a sigh, grabbing his arm and pulling on it. Toby looked sweetly at her.
"I w-won't Clockwork-" he started but Jane cut him off.
"Um, you have to. You picked the item." Toby seemed to be clutching the keychain for dear life for some reason. Shadowfire crossed her arms and cocked her head.
Toby choked out, "B-but I can't-" but Jane pushed Shadowfire and him roughly in the closet together and slammed the door shut.
Shadowfire and Toby went to opposite corners. Shadowfire had a disgusted look written on her face, and she looked down. "Why did you even get back together with Clockwork?" she asked flatly, trying not to let her emotions show.
She heard Toby grunt. "B-because I love her." Shadowfire felt a pang of jealousy slash right through her heart.
"I see," Shadowfire started in a whisper. "its just that I don't know what you see in her." her eyes finally turned a glowing red.
Toby moved closer to Shadowfire. "I-its not that I h-hate you." he said, hair ruffled.
"But you do." she replied. Her eyes were blurry with tears and she blinked them away. "I really liked you, Toby. I really did." Shadowfire added shakily. "I would die protecting you." her eyes turned the cloudy blue again.
Toby put a hand on hers. "Shadowfire."
She looked up at him, but before she could say anything, he kissed her, putting one arm tightly around her waist and the other on her shoulder. Shadowfire's eyes widened, but she closed them after a few seconds.
Toby undid her ponytail, running his hands through her hair. Shadowfire moved closer to him, their bodies touching gently.
After making out for a few more minutes, Jane creaked the door opened and then jumped back. "Whoa, look at that!"
Toby and Shadowfire broke the kiss but still stayed in each other's embrace. The both looked at the others, and Shadowfire laughed, putting Toby's mouth guard back over his lips. Toby gave her an eskimo kiss, and pulled off his mouth guard again, kissing her on the lips.
Shadowfire got up and brushed off her pants, Toby following after her.
"Oh and Clockwork, get lost." Shadowfire told the female with a glare.
They plopped down on the couch, and she put her legs on his and continued kissing him.
The other 'pasta's just stared at them. But she didn't care.
"I'm glad your back." Shadowfire said between a kiss.
"M-me too." Ticci Toby replied, but quickly put her lips against his again.